There are cover bands and tribute bands, and then there are bands who take the tribute to another level. One of those bands is Dark Star Orchestra, who recreate classic Grateful Dead shows in their entirety, as they were once performed. Enter Reprise, a band that does for Phish what DSO does for the Dead – but with the added bonus of not only playing a classic Phish show from the town/area they’re playing in, they also make it a point to have the show be as accurate as possible to the original performance, in terms of song length, antics, commentary, and even interplay between band members and crew.
On Saturday, November 2 at Lark Hall in Albany, Reprise – Cal Kehoe (Pink Talking Fish – guitar), Scott Chasolen (The Machine, Ulu – keys), Chris DeAngelis (Kung Fu, The Breakfast, RAQ, The Machine – bass) and Adrian Tramontano (Twiddle, Kung Fu, The Breakfast, RAQ, Marble Eyes, Mihali – drums) – brought to life one of Albany’s classic Phish shows, calling back to December 13, 1997, the Fall 1997 tour closer.
For me, this was not only my first Reprise show, but they were recreating the first Phish show I ever saw live. While my memories from that show are limited to “Sample in a Jar,” “Good Times Bad Times,” the lights going out during “Hood” and the cacophony of ‘bringing the Dude’ during “Mike’s Song,” I have relistened to that show more times than I can count. The tour closer stands out in one of Phish’s greatest tours, and begged for regular relistening to see what I missed that night when I was still a noob.
The show is chock full of jams, some rarities and new songs (for 1997) and some silliness that you only find at a Phish show when the band is dialed in and wrapping up a tour. I know this show by ear, and without looking at the setlist, let the show play out as it originally did just under 27 years ago, seeing what surprises were in store, but more importantly, how well Reprise did their homework on the recreation of the improvisation within the show.
To that end, as students of this particular show, they nailed the assignment with flying colors. The “Ya Mar” was played to nearly the same length as the original 18+ minute jumping off point for the show, including the end of the jam that never really ended the song proper. A good chunk of the first set beyond that may appear on paper to be pedestrian, but the tempo of the “Theme From the Bottom” ending, the 11-minute “Vultures,” and the thrilling “Tube” that gave way to a set closing ball of energy in “Good Times Bad Times” gave an ebb and flow to the show that lines up with the original show, no complaints registered.
The second set opening with “NICU” kept that free-flowing vibe going out of setbreak (were these the same length of time as well? A good question for manager Tom Marshall.) and into “Punch You in the Eye,” which never lets down but especially never in the second set. With dancing in “The Landlady” from Kehoe and DeAngelis, the full recreation is there, all the way down to the sudden intro of a ’97 “Ghost,” which is the jam of the night in both cases, overlooked for the “Mike’s” that follows, but still worthy of inspection.
Then again, that “Mike’s Song” is one of the odder things to catch at your first show, especially having no idea who this ‘Dude’ was they were suggesting to bring to the stage. The weirdness that Phish, and now Reprise, feed to fans amid an improv-vehicle is the launching point for the most furious part of this jam. By the time the weird returned in “Catapult,” wrapped up in a “Weekapaug Groove,” the set had flowed with the same ‘final show of the tour, all jams must go!’ intensity, wrapping up with a “Harry Hood” that saw the lights turned off, only a disco ball illuminating patrons and the stage.
The encore of “My Soul” paired with the sentimental “Squirming Coil” closed the night as Kehoe, DeAngelis and Tramontano walked off stage to cheers while Chasolen closed the song on piano, before departing the stage to cheers from a dedicated audience who hung on for every note of the show.
The only way this could have been more accurate (beyond the setbreak timing) is if an oddball opening act – ala J. Willis Pratt and Bionic, who opened for Phish this evening in 1997 – were to have performed ahead of Reprise.
Even though you can never go back and see your first show a second time, no matter how many times you relisten, Reprise offers the next best thing – four top notch musicians who do their homework, nail the songs and jams and master the interplay of Phish with self-assured panache.
Reprise plays Northampton, MA on December 19, 2024, recreating a classic show from the area. Tickets and more info here.
Setlist via Phish.net
Reprise – Lark Hall, Albany – Saturday, November 2, 2024 – recreating Saturday, December 13, 1997
Set 1: Ya Mar[1] > Axilla[2] > Theme From the Bottom, Ginseng Sullivan, Strange Design, Sample in a Jar, Vultures, Tube, Good Times Bad Times
Set 2: NICU > Punch You in the Eye > Ghost > Mike’s Song[3] -> Llama, When the Circus Comes, Weekapaug Groove -> Catapult -> Weekapaug Groove, Harry Hood
Encore: My Soul, The Squirming Coil
[1] Unfinished.
[2] Contained Axilla II ending.
[3] Chants to “Bring in the Dude.”
Ya Mar was unfinished. Mike’s Song included Foxy Lady quotes from Fish and some memorable vocal interplay from the band that included a chant to “Bring in the Dude.” During Hood, Trey asked Chris Kuroda to turn off the lights for a Blackout Jam and the audience responded with a shower of green glowsticks. The opening act was J. Willis Pratt & We’re Bionic.
Photos by Chris Bobillo
The post In Focus: Reprise Recreates Classic Albany 97 Phish Show appeared first on NYS Music.
